
A tenured media critic known working as a ghost writer, freelance critic for publications in the US and former lead writer of Atop The Treehouse. Reviews music, film and TV shows for media aggregators.

Omnesia’s take on “Dirty Love” isn’t just a cover so much as it is a controlled detonation of Frank Zappa’s original spirit, rebuilt with modern tools and a deliberately unstable sense of identity. Where Zappa’s version was sleazy, satirical, and knowingly grotesque, Omnesia approach the song like a piece of “future vintage” art; something dug out of the past, dusted off, and then immediately fed through a machine that asks uncomfortable questions about gender, performance, and intent. The result feels reverent without being precious, playful without tipping into novelty, and weird in a way that feels intentional rather than self-indulgent.
From the opening moments, it’s clear this isn’t a museum-piece homage. The groove locks in quickly, but it’s got elasticity to it, thanks largely to Robert John Tucker’s drumming, which walks a careful line between technical control and loose, almost chatty swing. There’s a confidence here that suggests deep familiarity with Zappa’s language without being trapped by it. Tucker’s lead vocal performance reinforces that idea. He doesn’t mimic Zappa’s sneer or exaggeration; instead, he delivers the lyrics like someone who understands the joke, enjoys the joke, and doesn’t feel the need to underline it in red marker.
Medella Kingston’s role is where this version really starts to mutate into something uniquely Omnesia. Her vocals don’t smooth out the song’s inherent absurdity; they bend it sideways. There’s an androgynous fluidity to her presence that reframes “Dirty Love” away from its original leering bravado and toward something more ambiguous and theatrical. The song becomes less about gross-out humor and more about performance itself: who’s speaking, who’s watching, and why it feels a little uncomfortable. It’s seductive, strange, and faintly destabilizing, like realizing halfway through a conversation that you’ve misunderstood the tone and deciding to stay anyway.
The supporting musicians elevate the track without drawing focus away from its central tension. Julie Slick’s bass work adds a muscular, melodic backbone that grounds the song even as it veers into odd angles, while Anthony Parker and M2’s guitar and keyboard textures layer in just enough unpredictability to keep things interesting. The production is polished but never sterile, letting the track feel alive, slightly unruly, and very human.
What ultimately makes Omnesia’s “Dirty Love” work is its comfort with contradiction. It’s tight but mischievous, respectful but irreverent, technically sharp while still feeling like it could derail at any moment. Like the best Zappa-inspired projects, it doesn’t demand analysis so much as participation. You’re meant to smirk, tilt your head, and enjoy the ride; preferably while wondering, just a little, whether you’re in on the joke or part of it.

A tenured media critic known working as a ghost writer, freelance critic for publications in the US and former lead writer of Atop The Treehouse. Reviews music, film and TV shows for media aggregators.